The Daily Southerner, Tarboro, NC

Opinion

February 6, 2013

Women in combat

ROCKY MOUNT — It sounds like our government has made the decision that women should serve in combat and it has become politically correct to fully support this and very politically incorrect to even question the validity of this decision.

I discovered very early in life that there is a difference between us males and females, and I really liked the difference…as the French would say, “Viva the difference.”  That difference spills over into the military, but we are now asked to ignore that difference and fully support the decision to allow women to serve in combat.  Perhaps before we accept that completely we should make note of some clear and concise reasons why this might not be such a good idea.

Here are some of the augments that maybe this isn’t such a great idea after all:

1. They may change the physical requirements so women can serve.  For example, an infantry man carries an average of 100 pounds of gear on his back.  Also he has to carry that load for a long distance and be able to scramble over walls with that weight.  A few women might be able to do this, but how many?

2. The Marine Corps has become more concerned about this than some others.  Male marines listed as some of their concerns as; fraternization, and personal issues that could affect the unit before they are sent to the battlefield.  Both male and female marines mentioned intimate relationships and the male marines feeling an obligation to protect female marines.  Women marines also questioned hygiene requirements and if they were captured would they be likely to be sexually abused?

3. Some requirements are straightforward. A tank shell weighs 40 pounds, and a member of a tank crew would need the strength to take the shell off the rack and load it in the main gun…and do this over and over again.  Again some weight lifting, body building women might be able to do this, but how many.

4. Former infantry sergeant John Lilyea, who served in the Persian Gulf war, said he believed that physical standards will be relaxed “in order to force the acceptance of women in the combat arms specialties.”  He also said that he didn’t think nearly as many of those in the military that say they support women in combat really feel that way.  His exact words: “I’m sure they all stood and saluted and said ‘yes sir’ and marched out smartly, but I don’t think they’re all 100 percent  behind it.”

5. In the Israel Defense Forces it was stated that their reason for removing female soldiers from the front lines was due less to the performance of female soldiers, and more due to the behavior of the male infantrymen after witnessing a woman wounded or killed.  The IDF saw a complete loss of control over soldiers who apparently had an uncontrollable, protective, instinctual aggression, severely degrading the unit’s combat effectiveness.  Maybe this was a result of the men being raised to be gentlemen and to respect ladies.  Should this be changed?

6. When it comes to basic training and infantry training, will we be called on to spend a great deal more of money in building new facilities?  If there are 100 soldiers in a training company then there would be about fourteen who would be women.  I don’t know how it is today, but when I lived in barracks, during my basic training, the latrines had about a ten foot long urinal and maybe 6 commodes lined up beside each other. I don’t think this would be the case today and certainly not with women in the same training company.  Would we then build separate barracks for the fourteen women? Since the liberals in congress love to spend money I suppose we would.

But, all women are for these changes that put women in combat, right?  Not exactly.  Elaine Donnelly of the conservative Center for Military Readiness and vocal critic for the new changes going into effect said that surveys showing results favoring women in combat asked the wrong questions.  The troops themselves should have been asked if they favored it and would it make a more effective force.  She said that the questionnaire relied on the “mistaken belief” that training standards will remain the same, which Donnelly said is not realistic given the physical abilities between the genders.

At this time we have an all-volunteer military, but this could change in the future and probably should change.  I personally feel that every physically fit and mentally fit high school graduate should have sixteen weeks of military training.  Even today males between the ages of 18 and 25 are still required to register for the Selective Service, and that’s a good thing.

To really be fair shouldn’t women, when they become 18 be required to register for the draft?  Anne Coughlin, a law professor said, “…there is no legal justification for saying that men alone need to shoulder that burden.”  And Col. Peter Mansoor, a professor of military history at the Ohio State University added, “If women are accepted to serve in combat, they are acceptable to serve whether they volunteer or not.  You can’t have frosting on the cake and not the cake underneath.”

But, we must remember that declaring that women should serve in combat is now politically correct and to be against this is politically incorrect.  So this new directive will stand.



(Bob Harper is a Tarboro resident who writes a column of general interest.)

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • The legacy of Joe W. Dickens Jr.'s dash

    Joe W. Dickens Jr.
    Sept. 14, 1953 - March 21, 2014
    The above statement is profound in its own way. It signifies the birth and the death of one of the most influential men in Edgecombe Coun

    March 31, 2014

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    On July 28, 911 was called because my husband had a bad headache. I was transferred to communications in Edgecombe County, where I spoke to a female operator. I informed her I needed Rescue because my husband had a bad headache and gave her our address and telephone number.

    September 26, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    Sheriff Knight’s “guys” may have worked hard on the case concerning Melvin Ray Fox, but did they really? Probably not for the sheriff, but for someone else behind the scenes. Not condoning Mr. Fox for his crime, because he should be punished, but not necessarily in the manner of leaving behind his wife as well as his 3-, 5- 7- and 13-year-old children.

    September 10, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    Concerning the Tarboro High 2013 Vikings football team: They have heart and desire. That was shown Friday night versus Washington. Just like last year’s state championship game, we got behind against a very good team. The Vikings didn’t quit even though they had several injuries throughout the game.  Right up to the last minute we had a chance  but, things didn’t go our way.

    September 5, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    It appears Mr. (Garland) Shepheard is shaking up things in our fair city according to a recent Daily Southerner article. Hurrah for him. This citizen, for one, believes the status quo needs a little shake up.
    I don’t know if Mr. Shepheard is disrespectful with his words and/or
    actions at council meetings or not. I don’t attend them any longer. It isn’t that I don’t care that some residents may suggest.

    September 4, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    Having just recently read the front page article in The Daily Southerner regarding Councilman Shepheard’s issues with the Tarboro town manager, I was left with more questions than answers.
    The article states that  Mr. Shepheard’s reasons for not voting in favor of extending the town manager’s contract had to do with “deplorable conditions of three town facilities, Thornton’s hiring practices and giving the council what he said was false information.” That’s it.  That’s all the information we were given.

    September 2, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    So who are you Mr. Allen Dennie Jr.? I have never heard of you. I have tried to find your voter registration on the North Carolina State Board of Elections website and I can't find it.
    Somebody said that you have an impressive resume. I say and ?
    But what I find interesting is the following. Mr. Dennie the current Sheriff is the following: "The sheriff of any county should be a person who has a personal interest in the citizens that work live and visit their county,"

    August 18, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    I am glad that opinions are being expressed regarding my actions at the Town Council meetings,  both by Mr. Walker and Mr. Wooten.
    It is my intention to expose the concerns expressed to me by the taxpayers of Tarboro, and when I find something that causes Tarboro not to be the Town we can all be proud of, I will speak up. I was told by people in Ward 8 when I ran for this office not to be like the rest of the Council and I expressed that to the members. The problems that exist in Tarboro should not have to be aired in public or at the Town Council Meetings and there should not be any discord.

    August 18, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    I am writing out of concern about disc golf. We as a town need to consider projects that have been given to (parks and recreation director) Cheryl Gay before this disc golf came along — like a walking trail at Clark Park, repairing the bathrooms, making sure the playground equipment is up-to-date and finding out what happen to the lights on the baseball field before we find money for disc golf. The town needs to consider what we been discussing in these last couple of meetings about recreation. I would love to see the Clark Park baseball field turned into a kickball field, which is a sport that everybody knows how to play, before you consider disc golf.
    Greg Higgs,
    Tarboro

    August 15, 2013

  • LETTER TO THE EDITOR

    To the Editor:
    Monday night at the Town Council meeting (Aug. 12, 2013), I witnessed some the most disruptive,vitriolic and asinine behavior that I’ve ever seen, in the person of (Ward 8) councilman Garland Shepheard.  For several months, his behavior has grown progressively worse and it seems to embolden him to waste my time, the time of the other council members and the time of other citizens who care enough about Tarboro to attend council meetings.

    August 15, 2013